Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33063265-20170910144543/@comment-33994734-20171229130723

@Gracehaperd ah yes true,

Well I don't like timetravel theories for one, even though Satella's words and the fact that Subaru had just done similar things with Emilia is quite evidently a hint at that. And sure you could say "Well maybe Emilia is a part of Satella" or something but then Subaru has quite evidently repressed memories of her too that don't seem to be directly linked to Emilia.

I wish I had an answer for this but I really can't put my head around these things. It would be so much simpler if Echidna could just tell it but then I guess she probably was asked not to or something. So that leaves Satella, Echidna, (potentially the dead witches), Pandora, the Dragon, Pack and Shaula with answers but of course it's not so easy.

Then there's Al x Envy, Al being linked to Subaru,..

About your edit, I'd have a counter-argument. Which is that Regulus and Echidna both had the genes at the same time, it's also fair to assume that Subaru has Greed at the same time as her now. And the hands of Envy look as though they're derived from the hand of Sloth, it's been speculated Satella has the genes of the last witches.

So I think there's something like multiple genes. As you said, we'll see.