Talk:Joshua Juukulius's Careful Encylcopedia/@comment-24727405-20180915010417/@comment-24727405-20180915145725

Of course it's weird, it's weird in a stupid way. Giving him only 1 arm is making him one of the weakest character along with Al and many other characters. Halibel is a rip-off of Ricardo, and Ricardo is ripping off Al. How would he give everyone a headpat like Subaru and Ana with only 1 arm? How would he scratch his head with only 1 arm? How would he fight and use a sword with only 1 arm?! The arm is still on the tower, right? You can just go there and reattach it. Otherwise, forgeting your arm is there and never existed it was the most stupidest idea ever. It's like saying trying to open an unlocked door without using a doorknob.

Josh only appeared in the 5th arc only to have his name and memory erased. Like I said, you can just written him out as a character and nothing will change.

Edit: And I know you read it, which is why i'm translating it with the power of Google Translate...and maybe you can post it on Reddit or your site for me. :)