Talk:Satella/@comment-196.75.63.49-20200917164541/@comment-99.203.16.74-20200925210819

I believe Satella is Emilia from another 'loop', and that Satella is trying to fix things in this loop so Emilia doesn't off half the world. During WWII the nuke was 'only' choice for ending the war with Japan without huge causties, what happens if Satella is that 'nuke' that although destorying half the world she saved the remainder? I am reasonably new to the story so please indulge my ignornance.

What do we know about the great calamity other then lots of poeple died, witches were 'eaten', and Satella being unable to die was sealed?

The witches except Dona seem to like her, Minerva though crazy is what I would consider the 'paladin' of that group, if Satella was evil she wouldn't stand for it, and she wouldn't of considered her Minerva's best friend. I sense that Satella blew things up to either stop more from being destoried or she was trying to do something noble and lost control. I would favor the former more then the later, that in sealing she knew she had done horrible things even if they were required to avoid even worse outcomes. So the sage, the saint and the dragon get to be the 'heros' while Satella endures the greif and blame. So much easier to give blame then take it as Geddy Lee sings (RUSH) in Freewill, look at Ried the man's a pig, but he's one of the three heros that "saved the world'.

As for being sealed Satella seems to have no problem breaking in places she shouldn't be, yes the 'seal' is intact, but 'leaky' according to the author, but what if it's Satella that out of guilt and duty is keeping herself 'locked' away. If she could crash Dona's tea party you are telling me that with all the damage done to tower she couldn't free herself if she really wanted too during one of Subaru's loops? Hell one of the obsticiles is her shadows, I think she allows herself to be 'sealed'.

Also Subaru's desire to save her and hers to 'die' maybe the same if Emilia becomes Satella. Possibly in the first loop Subaru meets Emilia frozen in the forest and frees her. Without Puck's guidence for those years she would have no idea of her powers and only a slight grasp of what happened. Subaru maybe great at unlocking her powers, but without a clue they would likely spend years just scraping by until Roswaal comes. Roswaal would have a greater influnce on both and would 'train' Emilia in her powers. Without Puck to provide blance she would lean on Roswaal and Subaru much more, of which only Subaru would want for her best intrests. So you have a wounded Emilia who with Subaru's help figures out Roswaal's games, her powers and that the world doesn't like her even if she hasn't done anything to it yet.

They go on with the same but different, they beat the white whale and hare, but each time are almost completely relient on Emilia's powers, which only grow with desperate use after desperate use. Rem fights her for Subaru rather then letting it slip aside, Ram doesn't become as much of a friend, Rienhard and Julius are more standoffish toward, the other candiates openly refuse to help anyone from her camp other then Subaru and Roswaal. Emilia is more and more isolated from eveyone but Subaru and Subaru can only do so much.

Maybe Dona hates Satella cause she knows the turth? That one of her expirements led to the Calamity, Emilia had to take in the Envy factor stop it and in stopping well half the world is ruined. It may of lead the witch of greed to do some safegaurds (ie Beatrice and Puck), allow Satella to take the blame and if Satella is Emilia she would, not to absolve Dona, but cause what she did was wrong and hurtful.

Through those same safeguards Satella may of influnced so that she could 'die' with the prefect Emilia living (hopefully married with Subaru and possibly Rem). Having seen the film in it's draft form Satella could edit it so, what went wrong the first time could go right this time! For Subaru to come and kill her could she means he ensures that circumstances allow Emilia either takes the Envy factor when she has the affinity to it, or avoids it all together and hence Satella is never born?

I don't think Satella is evil, I think something went hidousely wrong, I even think it was some other witch to do it. I also find it highly likely she was trying to save things rather then going on an insane rampage (though she might of). However if Satella did orginate from Emilia and has simalar if not the exact same morals and codes. You bet Satella would take the blame and lock herself away if all hell broke lose from her actions.

All this will lead Subaru to do something stupidly selfless (as usaul), likely once Emilia figures out about RBD (which I think she will), Once Satella has made enough progress through Subaru on the 'golden path'. With everything finally, finally going right Emilia will find a way to remove RBD to one make him stay safe (good look with that) and two to put her own buff on her Beloved. Subaru has one RBD left or Emilia underestimates his escape ablity and deterimation (both highly unlikely by arc 11, in five and six she has a keen feel on who Subaru is and seems to me to be getting a clue that something is special about him beyond his heart and will) and then to 'save' Satella he prevents the event that creates her killing him the last time. Emilia continues on, but is wounded by the loss providing the potential for another loop as it is highly likely that she over time achieves if not exceeds Satella's powers and having been by Subaru even more succesfully grown and nutured into what she acsends I would believe this Emilia would love him even more despately then Satella.

The un-happy ending is Subaru noble sacrifice (one made possible by Emilia trying to stop him from enduring pain and sacrifice by removing RBD) in it he does 'kill' Satella by making the conditions of 'her birth' invalid. Which may lead to Re: One Emilia's do over as I do not see her getting over Subaru and after all he does for her and others that she is the only 'being' that could love him more then Satella. Subaru dies for love, Emilia weeps, Satella is never born, but does Emilia open the gate again, does she allow herself to grow to goddess like stature and does she knowing what she knows now attempt for the platinium path? Does Emilia reach out her hand with all of her power and grasp the soul she loves the most? we have over five arcs to learn! Thank you.