Talk:Satella/@comment-45196231-20200928212651/@comment-99.203.17.241-20200929005036

There is a lot about the Great Calamity that isn't spelled out, if you are in Arc six, you get the sense that Fugel is at best a bit off, Ried the sword "saint" is an utter pig and we are just now seeing Volcanica at the end (maybe he will live up to expections?). We hear she devoured the other witches but none other then Echidna seem to harbour her any ill will. The way she supports Subaru and in her own manner wants him to 'save everyone' and to kill her paints to me a very different picture then a mad witch out to consume the world.

I won't say she is good, or a hero, but I would supose that either something got way out of hand, or in order to save half the world she had to destory the other half. Her wish for Subaru to kill her show she has at least remorse for what she did, and Subaru's desire to save her may end up granting both what they want.

What happens if Satella is Emilia from an earlier loop, a loop without puck to guide her, her loney soul with her vast powers reaches out and Subaru being Subaru is called to her from that loop. He frees her, he is there when she is cold, he holds her hand when she is lonely, he kisses her fears away. Satella falls (into an abyss...) in love with him, something happens that she does what must be done. Knowing Subaru and what is to happen she maniplates time, uses Echidina's tools for her purpose (Puck, Ros, Beatrice) to help prepare this Emilia, Satella is doing everything she can to set Emilia and Subaru on the 'GOLDEN PATH' so in 'saving' Emilia (and her), he invaidates the conditions for her birth (killing her). Just my thoughts, thanks!