Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-35245590-20180407225057/@comment-33994734-20180411185759

"Emilia = Satella" does make sense, I like it but I don't like that it requires time-travel so hopefully it can still be something else.

Another one is that Emilia was artificially created to become Satella's new vessel and such theories.

One argument for "Satella = Emilia" is when Satella says "Subaru gave her everything" she mentions things that he does with Emilia (especially the "you stayed by my side and held my hand", which he literally does a few chapters after that) but then again she remains pretty non-specific (thanks Tappei) so it could just be there to throw us off.

I mean that'd mean that she'd have had the same problems without the witch cult being a thing the first time around, which seems unlikely.

I feel knowing who Emilia's mother is might be some help here but we don't know much apart from the fact that she's human (most likely) and pretty powerful (from Pandora, I can't remember the exact line she said though) so that's not much help..