Thread:Angelo Gabrini/@comment-28083312-20200620055548/@comment-4436931-20200702015420

Ursuul wrote: Most of these low-edit users have their only contributions in comments already (or at least some of their contributions)...

You said, "Consider, that Discussions users are oftentimes purely social & not editors. It's quite likely that commenters will absolutely use Discussions", so I said that if they were planning on using discussions they would've already been using the comment sections and/or forum threads. I also said edits because comments are counted as edits, should I have said comments instead?

Just because comments aren't optimized for mobile doesn't mean there aren't any other ways. It's not like people only use their phones, PCs and tablets exist as well. Besides, comments not being optimized is fandom's problem and not mine

There are many powerusers & many casual (low-edit) users in both vote tallies. It seems to me that folks who want Discussions want to use the Wiki more, & Discussions is one way to more easily do that. Otherwise there's no point asking that it be enabled.

Of course the people who are voting yes want discussions enabled, but that's not what I'm trying to say. I'm just saying that people who are barely a part of the wiki shouldn't be allowed to vote, that's like me going to a different wiki and voting in an important poll. It makes no sense to me that "It seems to me that folks who want Discussions want to use the Wiki more" when they aren't even a part of the wiki in the first place. If you're not going to be a part of the wiki but you want a place to chat and discuss, just use reddit or discord