Talk:Natsuki Subaru

Error in a "Natsuku Subaru" Powers "Melee" about result a fight between Otto and Subaru.
Dont's has source about "...a fistfight between Otto and Subaru would always end in Otto's win...", in the ARC 4: ETERNAL CONTRACT PHASE 2, the author say about straight fistfight, not just fistfight about melee combat. In Chapter 31, Maid, Maid, Maid the author say: ". Subaru can't beat Otto in a straight fistfight, but that doesn't make Otto some amazing strong-guy." page 65. Otto is a great wizard, just won Subaru in one moment, but Subaru is a good atletic combatent, knocked off 3 thieves in the anime, but the Author never says in infinite possibilitys a combat between Otto and Subaru, all results is a Otto's victory, and if has, the writter this Wikia Topic, don't left the source. Ass: Aprile1992author

Hey. I'm the one who added that fact to Subaru's page. I'm not a Japanese speaker so I can't check the original source but from what I've read, the author did indeed state that.

Then again, twitter Q&As shouldn't be regarded as factual proof, considering how many mistakes and contradictions Tappei makes with those Q&As. Plus, he himself stated so.

Best regards Black Reaper Sasaki

I undestand about author replies, mainly in a tweet or answer yours fans, but a only source what I found in japanese or english in the internet, was in Arc 4, when Otto try talk with Subaru about Emilia, and the what I undestand in this moment in novel is about Subaru very angry in this situation, but don't mean what Otto can Win in all battles, of course what but of course Otto is a great mage, for being a being of this "new world", even more in the trader role, he is not a softie physically, but Subaru even by human standards, he is much stronger, knocking out in one of his incarnations the three thieves, but even in the interviews the author stated that he is not stronger than them, but he still won, in the Rank, Subaru just more strenght: Petra, Anastasia, Lewes(Real one) and Ferris. Just, but Subaru is an only human, and yours magics it depends on Beatrice. If don't has a confiable source about infinity possibilitys in the fight between Subaru and Otto with result is ever Otto's win, it's not a factual answer, since the closest source on this says that Subaru wouldn't just win a straight fight. Ass: Aprile1992author

Two things: 1, don't make a new section every reply, and 2, learn how to sign your posts, if you can't then post this on a message wall instead

As for the topic itself, the author's word is still canon compared to your opinion so the trivia still stands. If you want to argue that it's not accurate then bring an actual source other than your opinion

 Angelo Gabrini   (talk)   (contributions)  08:45, 5 May 2022 (UTC)

Hey Angelo, I'll just mention that a couple of weeks ago, Tappei held the 10th Anniversary Q&A over on that new Twitter Space feature and in it, he stated his Twitter and MySpace Q&As should be taken with a grain of salt as he usually comes up with the answers on the spot and tend to forget about them later. Furthermore, he contradicted himself on two very important topics, which just furthers his claim.

So the OP's concern is at least half sound. I'll look over it in the next couple of days tho I can't promise any changes as I specifically remember adding that trivia via a Q&A session.

Black Reaper Sasaki (talk) 09:39, 5 May 2022 (UTC)

While that may be true, an answer from the author is still an official and canon answer unless it's directly contradicted by a WN/LN source instead of "I don't think he can win all of them"

 Angelo Gabrini   (talk)   (contributions)  10:42, 5 May 2022 (UTC)

Angelo Gabrini and Black Reaper Sasaki, I'm use opinion? All things here, I show the Arch, Chapter and Page:https://witchculttranslation.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/a4-ph02-c024-c051-unrevised.pdf You aren't show the source about author quote about Otto's win in all moments again Tsubaru. You don't has education. I just say to Black Reaper Sasaki is about "Author Source", just this. I'm new in this Wikia, I can't use this tools, and in never moment I wasen't disrespectful to Black Reaper Sasaki, I just made an observation, because often the vocabularies from Japanese to English can be totally different and I believe that Black Reaper did not pass this information on in malice, maybe he really has this source or may have if mistaken, I just showed the source I researched on this subject and the only place it shows is in the Novel at the moment Subaru is in shock for not knowing what to do. Even Otto says that Subaru wasn't paying attention in that fight and the author makes that very clear, when Subaru and Otto at no time wanted to hurt each other, just to pass a scene where the "protagonist" needs a help to get back up, a clihcê of several animes like Inazuma Eleven, Dragon Ball, Naruto and etc. Now there's a quote that Subaru "NEVER" will ever beat Otto, I didn't think, just that he doesn't have a chance in a direct combat. Ass: Aprile1992author