Thread:Angelo Gabrini/@comment-4436931-20160818213417

"Who is the second one, I wonder? Satella? ...or Subaru? (Nah, Subaru's unlikely.)"

Still not explained

Aren't the IF Chapters "apocryphal"? (Let's guess Subaru ran off with Rem. Then Emilia was apparently killed by Petelgeuse and others. Then Pack started destroying the world. Then Reinhard killed Pack. What next? All those events didn't change that world at all? Hard to believe. I guess in that case something really bad would have happened to the world before Subaru's children were born.)

The IF Chapters do exist, they're spread out across the arcs as short stories unrelated to the actual story

True. Speaking of which, when Echidna presented the other witches to Subaru - how "genuine" were those? Specifically, when Subaru meets Satella at Echidna's "tea party", is it the real Satella or some kind of phantom created by Echidna? Turning it the other way around, from the real Satella's point of view: did Satella's spirit(?) really visited that party and met Subaru there? (Like, does Satella remember that meeting?) The synopsis is rather unclear on that matter.

Satella was real since she's still alive. Echidna wouldn't make a copy of her because she hates her. I guess she was a spirit like entity at the time, it's not really clear. She remembers what he said. The others witches are just their souls 