Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-35245590-20180407225057/@comment-44787697-20200403025733

I would like to add my own toughts about this topic.

I think there is a high probability that Satella is Emilia from another universe/reality or from the future.

Please pay atention to these three parts I extracted from the witch's tea party:

Satella: “I am in love with you. —Because you gave me light. Because you took me by the hand, and taught me the world outside. Because through nights where in solitude I shivered, you kept by my side with your hands around mine. Because, then being alone, by your kiss you told me I wasn't. There are so many things you've given to me. ...And so, I love you. Because you—you gave me everything.”

In this part Satella implies that she spent time with Subaru and came to love him after he gave her many things, in events that didn't happen in the history as we are accompaning Subaru since when he came from Japan. As this events didn't happen in the current chronology, these events could only have happened in another universe/reality or in the future.

Satella: “Always you. Always only you, am I in love with.”

I'm not sure but to me, it seems that she is repeating events and have fallen in love with him many times over or have been loving him for many years.

"Subaru: “Y... what are you!? What did you put in me!? Something like with RETURN BY DEATH, you put something in me to manipulate my heart!?”

Subaru feels something like love for Satella, even tough he should hate her. He feels a sense of nostalgia talking with her, like he is talking with someone he already knows. Logically he know nothing about Satella, but emotionaly speaking he knows that Satella is in fact Emilia.