Talk:Satella/@comment-180.191.234.10-20200320014007/@comment-44796386-20200324122149

1. This isn't Canon

Contra:

2. It is possible but it would ruin Emilias character since she fights against the descrimination coming from her looking like Satella and if she is Satella the descrimination would be somewhat justified.

3. The only character that can "time travel" is Subaru and how should he transport someone to a time where he wasn't even in the world

4. Time travel is a device that most authors use to have a plot twist e.g. Natsu being from the past and the younger brother of Zeref

5. We know that Emilia is Emilias true name since her name got eaten in one of the loops in Arc 6, why should she travel back in time and name herself Satella? She did it in the first loop ever, calling herself Satella, but why did she do that? I think it isn't that big of a plot point as the most people think, I think she did it to test whether Subaru knows the story of Satella and how he would react but I don't think she would do it again

6. I don't know how time travel in Re:Zero/your version of Re:Zero would work but Emilia being Satella and Satella killing Emilia in one loop after Subaru wanted to talk about RbD should effectively erase Satella from existence and would negate her granting Subaru RbD(even if RbD is a Authority, Pride being the only vacant one according to Petelgeuse and Typhon being killed, if her Authority would bring her back to life all witches wouldn't have died (except you say every death creates a parallel universe), what is unlikely. So after his Death in that timeline Subaru shouldn't be able to use RbD and he would be dead.

Pro:

7. There is no doubt that Emilia and Satella are somehow connected, Echidna calls Emilia the witches daughter, it can be assumed that Echidna is talking about Satella since she says that her hatred towards Emilia is partly because of Emilias Mother, Emilia, Satella and an undisclosed third person being the only three people Echidna hates. But Emilia is a half elf like Satella so she can't be her Mother since Emilias father, Fortuna brother is like Fortuna a "complete" elf and Emilia being only 115 years old and Satella being sealed in the Pleiades Watchtower for 400 years. So we can either assume Emilia is the daughter of another Witch, Minerva being a popular theory or Echidna tried to make a connection so it could be possible that Emilia is Satella

In conclusion it is possible but it isn't somewhere close to canon and Satella killing Emilia, herself in the past and not erasing herself from existence would be a minor plothole