Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33063265-20170910144543/@comment-29781768-20171229043558

No that wouldn't make any sense what so ever. How could Capella have the genes? That means that Flugel is confirmed to be dead. However, there is still a possability that Subaru is a reincarnation of Flugel. However, all these time travel thingies don't work without solid facts.

I would say that Subaru was chosen to be the new Flugel by the former Flugel.

Satella saying that Subaru was the one that gave her light is odd, as she didn't mention that Flugel was the one that gave her light. So Subaru = Flugel is a possability. But not on the Lust theories or the time travel theories.

Edit : Just so you know, there aren't many hints on this subject what so ever. However, only the witches we're shown to have Witch Genes. After they died, their succesors (witch cult) obtained them. It's impossible for Flugel/Subaru to have lust as Capella is still alive. However, the Gluttony parts becomes tricky, as that would mean there are 3 gluttony genes. Which will most likely be explained in Arc 6/7. We can only hope/theorize, but without solid facts or just "ifs and what if" a theory like this won't work.