Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-29781768-20171220214633/@comment-4436931-20171228130652

Alukardz wrote: My friend after his second death because he passed out in front of the fruit shop, he had to stay in the same spot he was summoned, Emilia passed by not long after, it is not a coincidence.

That still doesn't prove your point. Emilia and Felt simply happened to pass by at the time, if Subaru hadn't passed out during loop 3 he probably wouldn't have encountered her at all

There were and are are other people with authorities and I don't see any Archbishop of Sin saying "Oh you smell like Pride, Oh you smell like Sloth"

There are only a few characters that have been shown to smell/sense if someone has any of the authorities, namely Rem, Petelgeuse, and Shaula. It's not strange at all if most characters don't talk about Subaru's smell

and if he smells like Flugel because of the Witch Genes then surely you can't have the 2 of them several Witch genes at the same time, hence the same person

This point relies on the point before it (the part about Subaru being there 400 years ago) to be true. While it does sound reasonable, there's been no mention of any time traveling magic at all. I've seen a number of theories about this like Subaru being summoned once before, his dad was Flugel, and such, but in my opinion it's best to wait until it's properly explained