Thread:Emilia x Subaru/@comment-4436931-20200508101606/@comment-37883549-20200508104922

Well, that ending never happened in the LN version of Arc 3 (if I am recalling correctly, that loop ended up merged in the LN with the loop where Subaru dies by getting killed when possessed by Petelegeuse), which is why of course the BAD END didn't crop up in Arc 4. Whether the information Petelgeuse provided can still be treated as accurate, would probably be impossible for us to tell without asking the Author. But you mentioned that "but Puck still described his past appearence which looked like a human when he must leave Emilia.", so I'd like to check this interaction out if possible.