Talk:Satella/@comment-2003:E1:FF2A:BFCC:991F:87A5:2EC7:1AC9-20191005000457/@comment-16674955-20191014190104

Oh... wow...

"arc4 ch74"

...And?

[Echidna: The precise mechanisms of your Return by Death are unclear. It’s almost certain that the one facilitating your Return by Death is the Witch of Envy, but the issue of how the Witch of Envy causes you to Return by Death leaves questions unending. "

How is this proof in any way? Just because Echidna BELIEVES it? Just because Echidna SAYS it?

First of all "it's almost certain" does not make it a proof and neither does it make it true.

Secondly, why would I believe Echidna the manipulative witch who didn't care about lying to Subaru and actually did so?

Thirdly, do you believe a character stating something makes it a proof and the gives the author's seal of approval? Rem said that Subaru was part of the cult, does it mean it is true?

Well iam stating facts from the novel itself, so what else would be considered proof?"

It is not fact. It's hypothesis of a manipulative witch. I see no fact in there. And I see no proof.

If i remember it right, subaru even asked satella at the witches tea party why she gave him this power and she answered something like to protect his friends."

Yeah but actually no. She didn't answer. When Subaru says that she's the one doing it, she doesn't answer. All she says is that Subaru actually CAN save people but he shouldn't go at it alone all the time.

Even in the wiki page of satella it states the ability Time Manipulation "

And it's a fact, right? What some random person decides to write regardless of the actual truth?

If you deny my facts then you should actually try proofing me wrong with solid arguments."

I do not deny facts. I deny falsity that is always used for carroting people. We don't know. The only thing we know is that Subaru goes to the witch after death (in between RbD). That's the end of what we know. Who is it exactly who turns back time and how or why do they do it, we don't know. Actually, one of the trysts between Subaru and Satella actually proves that she isn't the one doing it. As they are together and then time starts again and Subaru has to leave. Another one as well, she wouldn't react the way she did when Suabru committed suicide when she took over Emillia in the sanctuary if she could just "yup, reversal, reversal, right at my command this instant".

You shouldn't use character hypothesis and opinion as fact/absolute truth. Character are their own being. They are not omniscient and they aren't the author.