Yeah they say that because they like Rem and feel their own opinion should dictate everything, Grace.
I truly want to see Rem happy but at this point even polygamy is purely irrational comforting. I have no doubt they truly care for each other and will continue so if she wakes up but I have serious doubts Polygamy would happen at any point.
From Love will sprout Jealousy, as demonstrated during Arc 6 with Shaula's appearance.
"---To seek love, demand it and take it all. Greed" No two people can take it all. No matter what this is not a situation where everyone can leave unhurt, that's the sad truth. I guess this is not completly out of the subject of the conversation since this is Love related after all but let us not descent into some kind of inferno. This is Satella's wiki page, we're not going to make a 65 page argument over whether Rem should somehow be the Heroin at the end. I'll answer no more than one comment regarding this.
I'm pretty sure the answer must be somewhere in the comments.
Emilia didn't want Subaru to get caught in her problem because she needed as few people as possible to know she'd lost the isigna (since people would think someone who can't look after an isigna could not possibly look after a whole country).
And so, as someone who's appearance matches that of the legendary Witch of Jealousy, she thought telling him her name was Satella would destroy his will to help her.
Of course once he died the world was reset back to before she had the idea or any reason to tell him her name was Satella, and so calling her that was really offensive to her partly because she knows that's what people think when they see her.
"Emilia = Satella" does make sense, I like it but I don't like that it requires time-travel so hopefully it can still be something else.
Another one is that Emilia was artificially created to become Satella's new vessel and such theories.
One argument for "Satella = Emilia" is when Satella says "Subaru gave her everything" she mentions things that he does with Emilia (especially the "you stayed by my side and held my hand", which he literally does a few chapters after that) but then again she remains pretty non-specific (thanks Tappei) so it could just be there to throw us off.
I mean that'd mean that she'd have had the same problems without the witch cult being a thing the first time around, which seems unlikely.
I feel knowing who Emilia's mother is might be some help here but we don't know much apart from the fact that she's human (most likely) and pretty powerful (from Pandora, I can't remember the exact line she said though) so that's not much help..
Maybe I'm out of the loop but, what do you mean "complete set"?
I doubt we'll get a nice box or anything, and even then I doubt the SS booklets will be included (sadly..)
You can just buy every book at once and have a "complete set" of what's currently out. Feel free to be more specific if that doesn't answer your question.
You think Echidna lied?
There's definitely details the witches didn't tell Subaru specifically because he was the sage candidate, like the fact that he's the sage candidate.
So I don't think that's far fetched. Or maybe she simply didn't know herself.
"I, forever, will love only you" -Dream Castel tea party, Satella (sane)
"I love you, Subaru-kun" -Arc 3 interlude, Satella (unclear state of mind)
I think this shows that she really knows who he is and is sincere about this. Although you could argue that the only time she's 100% sane she doesn't ever say his name and the times she does she's either not herself or it's unclear.
I don't think Kenichi would go back to having a normal life and hitting on teenagers after living there.
Well we know the authorities are not magic-based, at least not in the sense of using the user's Mana or Od.
It most likely has to do with Ying-Yang. The Authorities being Yin and the Blessings being Yang, which would explain the obvious similarities.
However the fact that it says "swallow the world" does point to what she did around the tea-party when she took over Emilia, which is more than likely related to Authorities rather than Mana.
I do like your theory though, I think it's well thought-out and quite possibly has a bit of truth to it as to why Beatrice was created in the first place and such.
@Gracehaperd ah yes true,
Well I don't like timetravel theories for one, even though Satella's words and the fact that Subaru had just done similar things with Emilia is quite evidently a hint at that. And sure you could say "Well maybe Emilia is a part of Satella" or something but then Subaru has quite evidently repressed memories of her too that don't seem to be directly linked to Emilia.
I wish I had an answer for this but I really can't put my head around these things. It would be so much simpler if Echidna could just tell it but then I guess she probably was asked not to or something. So that leaves Satella, Echidna, (potentially the dead witches), Pandora, the Dragon, Pack and Shaula with answers but of course it's not so easy.
Then there's Al x Envy, Al being linked to Subaru,..
About your edit, I'd have a counter-argument. Which is that Regulus and Echidna both had the genes at the same time, it's also fair to assume that Subaru has Greed at the same time as her now. And the hands of Envy look as though they're derived from the hand of Sloth, it's been speculated Satella has the genes of the last witches.
So I think there's something like multiple genes. As you said, we'll see.
He might very well to be honnest, good one Cents
I wasn't saying that at all.
I said that as in he wouldn't use a name that has nothing to do with the rest of the names and that is not documented in Japanese. Obviously mythology, constellations and such is documented. "Satella" is unlikely to be found anywhere, Stella on the other hand is and is much more linked to stars.
Now of course it could also be Satellite but why when literally everything else in the cult is based around stars?
Yes however it's fairly clear that this is what it is supposed to be. A bit like Petelgeus is obviously Betelgeus, star-wise.
Which this too is to be answered and voluntary.
So I don't think Satella was intended as anything but a variation of Stella, seeing as the name is reaaally rare and completely unrelated. Keeping in mind Tappei is really bad with foreign languages it should either be related to a satellite (unlikely) or Stella.
The reason as to why he used Satella over Stella/Sutella being a main subject in the mystery. like Petelgeus. (Quite likely linked to Pandora in a way yes but this not being the only possibility at all.)
So to answer your question, it's wildely accepted that Subaru was in that world at the same time as Satella even if not as Flugel.
Then becoming Satella's first and only Love.
As Subaru is a sage candidate and Shaula recognizes him as Flugel (she has poor vision so it's no confirmation at all) it's also wildely thought he IS Flugel. Few other alternatives can be risen as of now, the only alternative I can see being Pack (other theories have people being split into multiple people so it's also possible Subaru and Pack might be parts of Flugel. It's just wild guessing for now though.).
Adressing another point from your post:
Satella loved Subaru from at the very least the day of his (last) summoning, as shown in the dream castle chapters. It's only at the end of these dream castle chapters that she asks that he comes and kill her, to which he replies he will save her. She however couldn't reply to this as the dream world faded at that time. So answering "I'll definitely save you" was not a factor in that Love.