So it is confirmed that Priscilla has immense luck, but is it actually luck? Could it be that Priscilla is Pandora and Al is actually the Sin Archbishop of Pride. There are sooo much hints given towards this small theory. In my opinion, it could be possible. These hints gave me the theory :
Priscilla isn't her real name
Priscilla is Prideful, Pride = Vainglory in different Language.
When Priscilla was young, she was known as a "human sacrifice", could this be a hint for a sacrifice for the witches?
Priscilla's luck is insane. It could be the Authority of Vainglory that helps her do this.
i disaggree on that one. The Priscilla camp in general is so suspiscious.
What my theory lacks is the Arc 5 part. Why would Aldebaran and Pandora (priscilla) fight Capella and Capture Sirius? I'm still really positive on my theory, Aldebaran knows too much about the Archbishops and Priscilla shows almost all the qualities that Pandora (could) have.
There's also the fact that Priscilla predicted where Subaru would go in arc 3 and that he would want to enter the castle (she even told Al what Subaru would say), you can check the manga. She might have a gospel.
I also remember someone on 4chan saying Emilia instinctively disliked her as soon as she saw her, which would make sense given her past with Pandora, but I don't remember the source.
Imo she's definitely linked to Pandora. This having been said, I think it's more likely that she's just Pandora's pawn and not Pandora herself. If Priscilla is supposed to be her cover then she's making it way too obvious given the way she acts, though you could argue that's not a big deal because the only character on Subaru's side who knows about her is Emilia and she'd be too dumb to figure that out. On the other hand if Pandora is indeed the main villain it'd be weird to have her show up only in flashbacks until very late in the story, so having her disguised as Priscilla would make sense.
I have to disagree, the author's already shown that Priscilla does actually exist and considering she acts the same way at home (Sunlight on the Water) it's not really an act. None of your evidence except for the last one have anything to do with your theory, and even then it's just speculation. I'm still leaning toward Subaru having it based on his Returns by Death being described as one and Shaula's words
What my theory lacks is the Arc 5 part. Why would Aldebaran and Pandora (Priscilla) fight Capella and Capture Sirius? I'm still really positive on my theory, Aldebaran knows too much about the Archbishops
I might be forgetting something but where does it show that Al knows too much about the Archbishops? As far as I know he was just acquaintances with one. As for Sirius, they'd fight her because she's an enemy of Lugnica
There's also the fact that Priscilla predicted where Subaru would go in arc 3 and that he would want to enter the castle (she even told Al what Subaru would say), you can check the manga. She might have a gospel
Gospels show the holder's future in little detail, so I doubt it'd tell her to pick up Subaru. She probably figured he would through their exchange the previous day
I've been reading Q&As lately, in one of them Tappei said that witch genes would remove any blessings the host used to have (it seems witch genes and blessings are incompatible), so Priscilla can't be Pandora since she has a blessing.
He also said that Priscilla's luck wasn't really an ability, which seems to imply it's something external, for example Pandora's influence.
I don't think she's related to the witch's cult or at least directly, I have no proof or theory, just call it a hunch.
she never striked me as cultist...maybe being manipulated by them somehow without her knowing
isn't far fetched in fact it's very probabable, maybe it will be a shock to her if that was the truth.
you can't guess what she's thinking
but I think her motives lies elsewhere, in her birthplace maybe, which probably where arc 7 will take place in the Vollachian Empire
Al is said to be connected to one of the 3 big secrets of Re:Zero so there will be more about him in the future that's for sure
but personally, I wish she turns to be a good person eventually, she's a b*tch but she doesn't seem to be bad person with evil intention at heart, at least for me, and I hope her relation with subaru gets better and finds out she's wrong about him and show him a bit of favor
I know my opinion is very cliche, but the heart wants what the heart wants
Priscilla probably is not a sin archbishop but might have gained the witch factor for pride when her relative Stride Vollachia died. Stride's former affiliation with the witch cult is probably how she got to know what she knows about the witch cult. So in summary, she's a person like Subaru who has a witch factor but does not work with the witch cult.