FANDOM


  • This is just a random theory I came up with on the spot but what if Emilia is Satella's half-sister, it is probably incorrect but it seems plausible to me. Anyway, so the theory is that 400 years ago an elf and a human had Satella, obviously she went nuts and swallowed half the world but what if 300 years later (after Satella was sealed) the same elf had another child with another human (considering elves live for quite a long time this seems reasonable), so maybe the reason Satella and Emilia look similar is because they share the same mother/father (whatever one was an elf). I prefer this over the Satella is Emilia's mother theory but the theory stating that Emilia is Satella in the future just gone back in time would explain why they look exactly the same. Still I think my theory is interesting. (I have only read up to ch74 of arc 4)

      Loading editor
    • Satella and Emilia don't look similar, they are nearly identical. Also, Lia's father is the elf. The reason why this theory is impossible is because the mother genes would be different, which isn't valuable in this theory as they look Exactly the same.

        Loading editor
    • Thanks, it seems the Emilia being Satella theory is more logical, just up to the point I am in the web novel I cannot fathom a reason for Emilia becoming Satella or any reason for why Emilia looks identical to Satella but there most likely is more info on this further on in the web novel.

        Loading editor
    • Let's get ideas.Who is satella ?

        Loading editor
    • "Emilia = Satella" does make sense, I like it but I don't like that it requires time-travel so hopefully it can still be something else.

      Another one is that Emilia was artificially created to become Satella's new vessel and such theories.

      One argument for "Satella = Emilia" is when Satella says "Subaru gave her everything" she mentions things that he does with Emilia (especially the "you stayed by my side and held my hand", which he literally does a few chapters after that) but then again she remains pretty non-specific (thanks Tappei) so it could just be there to throw us off.

      I mean that'd mean that she'd have had the same problems without the witch cult being a thing the first time around, which seems unlikely. 

      I feel knowing who Emilia's mother is might be some help here but we don't know much apart from the fact that she's human (most likely) and pretty powerful (from Pandora, I can't remember the exact line she said though) so that's not much help..

        Loading editor
    • Her mother is confirmed to be human. Her father is a full elf, and is Fortuna's brother. The reason why Fortuna became incredibly angry is because Pandora is the reason why her brother and her sister-in-law died.

        Loading editor
    • Satella speaks as if he had lived the same moments as emilia. Thank you for saving me, Subaru-kun, etc.

        Loading editor
    • Gracedharperd wrote: Satella and Emilia don't look similar, they are nearly identical. Also, Lia's father is the elf. The reason why this theory is impossible is because the mother genes would be different, which isn't valuable in this theory as they look Exactly the same.

      In addition, we can see Emilia's body among the dead lying on the floor as Subaru approaches Satella in the trailer for season 2.

        Loading editor
    • That's not Satella, that's Echidna.

        Loading editor
    • also don't take that trailer as for real it'll be explained in the season proper just know that that hill and all those bodies isn't real.

        Loading editor
    • It isn't litteral, it's a sort of teaser. It's put in perspective. So it's more like symbolism while at the same time representing what the next arc will be about. And I can clearly tell you that, if you had read arc 4, you'd realize how accurate it is. So nothing of that "trailer" is canon but it does represent the arc perfectly. 

        Loading editor
    • Who is she? Well, that is the one question we can't possibly have the answer right now.

        Loading editor
    • satella is different route emilia who get ouma jiou's power ^_^

        Loading editor
    • I have only watched the anime, but I'll drop my theory anyway:

      Emillia and Subaru become lovers, but due to their different life spans Subaru inevitably dies first, leaving her in despair. By some means, she goes back in time to be ruinited with him. Perhaps much further back as a means to amass the power needed to guide Subaru down the path to immortality, by preventing him from ever dying, and perhaps helping him to gain power of his own. Obviously a lot of paradoxes would be involved, but if Satella = Emillia turns out to be true, then paradoxes are unavoidable anyway.

        Loading editor
    • Yeah but Returns by Death doesn't grant immortality. If he were to die of old age then he would just keep going back in time to a check point then dying of old age again.

        Loading editor
    • 82.4.150.105 wrote:

      Gracedharperd wrote: Satella and Emilia don't look similar, they are nearly identical. Also, Lia's father is the elf. The reason why this theory is impossible is because the mother genes would be different, which isn't valuable in this theory as they look Exactly the same.

      In addition, we can see Emilia's body among the dead lying on the floor as Subaru approaches Satella in the trailer for season 2.

      well i dont think that trailer is the actual reality where subaru lives in i think hes just being messed with because there were a few people that couldnt be in the same year or they would be supe old but there bodies dont look old in the trailer so i think echidna is messing with subaru's or like testing him cus looking at his face he was really focused and mad at the same time, he was also really hurt as you could see at the start by the way he walks and then when he sees more bodies hes starting too walk a little more confident and by his face i could imagine that echidna did something or is training him in some kind of way to face a threat (that could maybe be the rest of the witch cult or the spirits of the witches of sin) ive only watched the anime and im trying too find the manga online but no luck.

      and back too the dead bodies as i already said: all these people cannot be together at the same time.

        Loading editor
    • I would like to add my own toughts about this topic.

      I think there is a high probability that Satella is Emilia from another universe/reality or from the future.

      Please pay atention to these three parts I extracted from the witch's tea party:

      Satella: “I am in love with you. —Because you gave me light. Because you took me by the hand,
      and taught me the world outside. Because through nights where in solitude I shivered, you kept by
      my side with your hands around mine. Because, then being alone, by your kiss you told me I wasn't.
      There are so many things you've given to me. ...And so, I love you. Because you—you gave me
      everything.”

      In this part Satella implies that she spent time with Subaru and came to love him after he gave her many things, in events that didn't happen in the history as we are accompaning Subaru since when he came from Japan. As this events didn't happen in the current chronology, these events could only have happened in another universe/reality or in the future.

      Satella:
      “Always you. Always only you, am I in love with.”

      I'm not sure but to me, it seems that she is repeating events and have fallen in love with him many times over or have been loving him for many years.

      "Subaru: “Y... what are you!? What did you put in me!? Something like with RETURN BY DEATH, you put something in me to manipulate my heart!?”

      Subaru feels something like love for Satella, even tough he should hate her. He feels a sense of nostalgia talking with her, like he is talking with someone he already knows. Logically he know nothing about Satella, but emotionaly speaking he knows that Satella is in fact Emilia.

        Loading editor
    • Angelo Gabrini
      Angelo Gabrini removed this reply because:
      Spam
      07:40, May 26, 2020
      This reply has been removed
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.